公仔箱論壇 - Powered by Discuz! Board

標題: Vs 妙手仁心/壹號皇庭 [打印本頁]

作者: shibala 時間: 2013-11-12 09:32 AM 標題: Vs 妙手仁心/壹號皇庭

點解 tvb 唔可以拍返好似以前嘅妙手仁心呢 ??
我覺得妙手同壹號皇庭呢d 真係好經典, 同埋都用咗起碼 3 個 season 去 build  個 character, 就咁拋棄嗮佢地又換班新仔入嚟, 但係來來去去都係0個d 情情塔塔死伴侶嘅橋,  + \7 s# Z" ~+ @# `
咁我不如睇返啊林保怡個懶浪子嘅 character  同程至美個 professional 嘅情深 look ...  $ n( H5 l, q4 s

即係唔係話唔可以開d 新戲俾d 新血做d 新經典...www1.tvboxnow.com% ^' T: C* E/ k- P& g. a% J: G
不過你都真係寫得好 d 先可以係經典...
好似第一集咁, 作為一個神經外科醫生又點可以係 car accident 嘅  trauma scene 入面表演老到, 即係我醫院入面見 d 做咗 10+ years 大醫生個d 就連係本科都冇佢咁定lor ...  =_=  + k' \7 i6 [( D! j) w4 {, G' k
www1.tvboxnow.com" O* h; i5 {* R. k( O6 a
同埋兩套劇其中最正嘅唔只佢地呢班 professional 點去 professionally 面對佢地嘅 career
係放工后去個好有 feel 好 elegant 嘅  lounge 睇到你好想即刻去考個醫生/lawyer 牌呀嘛
而家班細路放工去浦打邊爐...... -_- sigh....  世界變lor

作者: mrfusion 時間: 2013-11-12 05:19 PM

I think we need to stop compare with old classic, not every drama can become classic, On Call definitely can't.

作者: lqs6606959 時間: 2013-11-14 11:01 AM

还是原来的配方，还是熟悉的味道

作者: karrwong 時間: 2013-11-17 05:51 AM

There one one formula. It just depend on how you adjust it.

作者: lys25 時間: 2013-11-17 08:07 AM

我覺得妙手真係好D

作者: bigheadson 時間: 2013-11-17 09:32 AM

因為好既導演走晒...

作者: gssanime 時間: 2013-11-19 12:03 PM

I think this one give the general public more insights as the how things runs in hospitals and some common issues faced in the hospital but in a more layman term.

作者: swdlhk 時間: 2013-11-20 01:48 AM

2套戲都一樣架啦

作者: ibm128 時間: 2013-11-20 09:46 AM

That is why this drama needs 程至美 back for some hope to regain some audience back, but fails at the end.

作者: pctan0306 時間: 2013-11-23 08:33 AM

觉得on call 1 比较好看点。

作者: nestofhk 時間: 2013-11-23 08:12 PM

我覺得妙手真係好D我覺得妙手真係好D!!

作者: terrytam 時間: 2013-11-24 09:23 AM

以前既點都好過依家果d

作者: kenyiu97 時間: 2013-11-25 07:33 PM

不能比.

作者: bigkingkong 時間: 2013-11-28 08:39 PM

往事只能回味

作者: 0o王子o0 時間: 2013-12-1 08:49 PM

妙手妙手妙手妙手

作者: 松111 時間: 2013-12-2 11:54 AM

肯定是妙手好呀演员阵容强大导演也给力剧情吸引非常期待TVB重播一下以前经典的剧集高清版的好收藏

作者: hashonet 時間: 2013-12-3 12:46 AM

可惜沒能超越妙手仁心。
感覺上選角還是有問題，雖然角色年輕化，但是演技似乎還無法提升劇本質感。TVBNOW 含有熱門話題，最新最快電視，軟體，遊戲，電影，動漫及日常生活及興趣交流等資訊。0 y. S$ x3 M' j, v
而像有實力的演員們的戲份都輕飄飄的，根本沒辦法讓劇情引人入勝。

個人認為劇本最大敗筆就是一直追著這『兩姊妹』，讓人感覺劇本無法向其他國外醫務劇看齊，但又一直想要強調新增人物的關係，變相編織了一張巨大的網，觀眾的觀賞距離卻只能一小塊。www1.tvboxnow.com4 J; Z. r0 t3 [% Y* }. c! G3 Q& d

增強了親情與朋友、暗戀與失戀、遺憾與不再遺憾、著緊與放不下，被一堆情緒纏住，其實讓觀眾看得挺不知所措。公仔箱論壇" X: ^: n: x1 g$ f( M, P

例如醫護人員之間的衝突，基本上都變成很淺薄的罵，或許偏向寫實，但也讓人感觸不深，難以代入與理解。; N3 V) B& b( }" e8 ?$ P. v

個人覺得，這個劇缺點多於優點。

作者: 大文細佬 時間: 2013-12-5 12:55 AM

可能我要求高咗.... 唔知點解e+有時睇番TVB啲舊劇覺得都係唔係咁掂...

作者: ~chopper~ 時間: 2013-12-6 11:56 PM

編劇太差

作者: stressedout 時間: 2013-12-7 03:50 AM

it would have been better if they did a healing hands and on call crossover

作者: pctan0306 時間: 2013-12-7 12:44 PM

妙手好看点吧！

作者: chinchiu2004 時間: 2013-12-13 07:27 PM

我覺得On Call 36小時第一集好過續集

作者: oblivious 時間: 2013-12-16 10:51 AM

I don't think we should compare the two. One's definitely had longer runs than the other... But still this second installment isn't as good as the previous one. On call 36 I, I think, has a much better storyline than II. On call 36 II is pretty mediocre; I think the best part is the storyline between 香香and 羅仲謙, especially towards the end.

歡迎光臨公仔箱論壇 (http://www1.tvboxnow.com/)